Gate upgrade at Island Lake Dam

About this project

client
Minnesota Power
location
northern Minnesota
cost
$321,000 (Barr's fees)
completion date
2019

Awards

Engineering Excellence Grand Award
ACEC/MN  2021

The century-old Island Lake Dam not only regulates water levels and supports recreation on the Island Lake Reservoir, but also supports generating power for Minnesota’s largest hydropower system. When Minnesota Power identified a critical problem—five leaking sluice gates causing a reduction in power generation and posing operational, environmental, and safety risks—it turned to Barr for assistance.

Designing and implementing dam repairs called for special precision. The gates’ location, 50 feet below the water’s surface meant divers couldn’t safely access the gates for repairs. An additional complication was that the dam’s original design called for partial drainage of the reservoir to access the gates, and this option was no longer feasible.

Barr performed an options study for a replacement design that would improve gate integrity and reliability. Once a design was selected, close collaboration among Minnesota Power, Barr, and construction contractor J.F. Brennan Company, Inc., along with the use of a three-dimensional model, enabled development of a final design and detailed construction plans.

The design configuration extended the end walls and piers vertically by 30 feet. New bracing and framing were added to distribute loads. Bulkhead slots accommodated steel bulkheads for dewatering. Finite-element models were used to assess load stresses and size new elements to help assure structural integrity and stability. As gate design was developed, Barr also conducted a potential failure mode analysis (PFMA) to help assess the risks associated with the design’s construction, operation, and long-term maintenance.

This repair and restoration project received a 2021 Grand Award in Engineering Excellence from the American Council of Engineering Companies of Minnesota.

Key team members

Tor Hansen

Vice President
Senior Civil Engineer

Whitney Hansen

Vice President
Senior Civil/Structural Engineer

Bill Forsmark

Vice President
Chief Marketing Officer

Related Hydro projects

Landfill-gas monitoring at remediated dump to support brownfield redevelopment
Air dispersion modeling for distributed-generation plant
Landscape master plan for watershed district
O&M manual for green-infrastructure stormwater BMPs
Third-party transmission-line construction monitoring
Design of abutment wall extension at Dells hydro station
Design and prioritization of spillway gate repairs
Engineering design for HDD pipeline replacement under highway
Incident energy and arc flash hazard analyses of three facilities
Natural-resources management plan for suburban park
Feasibility design and inspections of an urban stormwater-management tunnel
Engineering services and permitting assistance for Bison 2 and 3 wind farms
Dam safety consultations for SaskPower
Geotechnical, structural, and civil work for Canadian wind farm
Electric-energy resource options study
Design services for solar generation facility
Mine closure and reclamation
Monitoring of constructed wetland for groundwater remediation
Study of engineering risks and site feasibility for windpower client
Stormwater storage facility for major Minneapolis interstate artery
Water-quality and sediment-dredging study to restore a phosphorus-impaired lake
Environmental review for proposed natural-gas pipeline
Waste-gas scrubber design engineering for taconite pellet plant
EMIS implementation and related assistance
Installation of new auxiliary boilers for power plant
Inspection and repair of urban stormwater tunnels
Responding to wind-farm tornado damage
Bridge movement monitoring
Evaluation of wind-turbine foundation following fire damage
Engine compliance tool update
Natural resources master plan
Embankment stabilization along Highway 73
Test burn for cofiring coal and biomass
Transmission line EIS
Flood forecast mapping for city's emergency response and planning efforts
Air-quality permitting and compliance support at pipeline terminals
Environmental permitting and compliance support at terminals
Improvements to municipal flood-risk-protection system
Monitoring and maintenance of remediation system at wood-treating site
Groundwater-surface water study of McKenna Lake
Permitting and wetland delineation for a community solar garden
Highway 55 storm-tunnel inspection
Penstock replacement at McClure Dam
Highwall stability assessment
Options study and design to restore biomass fuel-handling system
Infrastructure inspection program for Minnesota watershed district
Air permit-to-install strategy and application
Steam-line evaluation at Rapids Energy Center
Air quality permitting for distributed-generation plant
GHG compliance monitoring for oil sands facility
Air-quality-permitting support for refinery assets
Site reviews for solar gardens across Minnesota
Whitewater State Park stream restoration
Hennepin County sustainable landscape guidelines
Spillway design for iron-ore-mining and mineral-processing facility
Water quality and ecological improvements to an urban lake
Groundwater compliance assistance for CCR Rule
Developing health assessment tools for wind-turbine towers and foundations
Hydrology and hydraulic modeling of a tunnel system
Condition assessment and options study for hydro facility
Floodproofing of utility switchyard
Concept-level design of wastewater discharge option
Vapor-mitigation implementation and maintenance at business center
Environmental review and permitting for natural-gas-distribution projects
Minnehaha Park lower glen restoration
Design of an LED lighting system for a downtown streetscape
Fast-track realignment of a storm sewer
Environmental review for peaking plants
Municipal drinking-water wellhouse evaluation and design
Engineering and design services for new truck dumper
Restoration of trout habitat in Vermilion River
Solar-energy-system compliance
Auxiliary boiler installation
Remedial investigation, negotiation, and design for Superfund site
Stormwater-development reviews for an urban watershed district
Retrofit engineering for ash conveyance
Energy integration study for waste-heat utilization
Environmental services for coal-yard decommissioning
Option study and design for air jig dewatering system
Permitting, design, and construction oversight for CCR surface impoundment
Groundwater modeling for water-supply wellfield expansion
Transmission-line permitting assistance
Structural and electrical engineering for coal-dryer load-out improvements
Environmental review for natural gas pipelines
Poplar Bluff substation upgrade
Transmission line upgrades for reliable power delivery
arc-flash analysis at Coal Creek Station
Study of solar developments on closed Minnesota landfills
Geotechnical investigation for the East Valley Battery Storage Facility
Geotechnical investigation of pumped-storage hydroelectric facility
Preliminary geotechnical engineering and geophysical investigation
Willow River Dam rock arch rapids design services
Seneca solar project geotechnical engineering services
Conceptual development for Coal FIRST initiative
Pre-FEED study for Coal FIRST initiative
Civil engineering services for 10 MW solar facility
Structural analysis and evaluation of powerhouse
Permitting assistance for partial repowering of wind facility
Environmental review and permitting for windfarm repowering
Mitigation of aerosol impacts from coal combustion
Spillway redesign at Cedar Falls Hydro Generating Station
Air-quality services for steel company
Hydropower facility evaluation and improvement recommendations
PMF modifications at hydroelectric plants
Design for spillway replacement at Bond Falls Dam
Hastings levee certification
Crane walk geotechnical engineering at Kings Point wind site
PMF study for the Dead River
Analysis of microbial ecology in selenium bioreactor
Statistical analysis of coal-silo vibrations
Cyclic degradation geotechnical evaluation for wind turbine foundations
Upgrades to mineral processing plant
Calculating stormwater fees via remote-sensing technology
PFAS treatment during power plant decommissioning
Acid-generating rock identification and mitigation
Solar on reclaimed coal mine, settlement and subsidence risk analysis
Blaine water treatment plant 4
Permitting and nondegradation services for sugar-beet facility
Cathodic protection design for pipeline projects
Grassy Point and Kingsbury Bay habitat restoration
Engineering and design for the rehabilitation of Karey Dam
Tailings dam safety inventory and semiquantitative risk analysis
Park and water-feature evaluation and renovation
Rock-fall protections at Interstate State Park
Air permitting assistance for manufacturing coating facility
Redesign and optimization of crystallizer piping
Environmental support for solar power facilities
Desktop study and geotechnical investigation for new wind power site
Permitting and field review for natural gas pipeline replacement
Wind farm repowering structural assessment
Renewable energy development plan
Multi-phase levee alterations for the City of Des Moines, Iowa
Carbon-capture-system feasibility study
Third-party dam safety review of tailings-storage facility
Implementing a dual fuel system for peaking plant