search
menu

Statistical analysis of coal-silo vibrations

About this project

client
Falkirk Mining Company
location
North Dakota
cost
$75,000
completion date
2019

At its coal mine near Underwood, North Dakota, Falkirk Mining noticed unusual vibrations occurring in its silo during certain periods. Concerned about the silo’s structural stability, the company asked Barr to investigate the cause. 

Our structural engineers installed four vibration and displacement sensors at various heights on the silo to record data multiple times a second. Barr’s cloud-based data-warehousing system processed the high-frequency instrumentation data into hourly and daily averages for analysis. We then used statistical fingerprinting techniques to identify the specific characteristics of the vibrations when they occurred, and with the client’s assistance, identified previous dates on which those types of vibrations had taken place.

The real-time instrumentation data showed that the silos were swaying slightly and vibrating at a frequency centered on 1.25 Hz. Barr theorized that differences in the coal level in the silo were affecting the mass distribution and creating the vibrations, and conducted a dynamic structural analysis to test that theory. We used the results to (1) demonstrate that the vibrations were not caused by activities linked to specific days of the week or external loading conditions, and (2) help Falkirk Mining evaluate several hypotheses about the circumstances causing the vibration.

Our analysis of the vibrations and their inferred stresses indicated that the vibrations were likely the result of non-uniform vertical flow patterns in the coal mass inside the silo, and did not threaten the structure’s stability.

Key team members

Joel Swenson

Senior Geotechnical Engineer

Paul Schiller

Vice President
Senior Structural Engineer

Ryan Rayda

Senior Structural Engineer

Related operations projects

Landfill-gas monitoring at remediated dump to support brownfield redevelopment
Air dispersion modeling for distributed-generation plant
Landscape master plan for watershed district
O&M manual for green-infrastructure stormwater BMPs
Design and prioritization of spillway gate repairs
Phase I ESA for copper-nickel project
Alternatives evaluation for repairs or replacement to Odland Dam and spillway
Ore transportation study
Dry-stack tailings management
Engineering design for HDD pipeline replacement under highway
Permitting, environmental assessment, and design for copper-nickel mine
Tailings basin expansion and closure options
Incident energy and arc flash hazard analyses of three facilities
Natural-resources management plan for suburban park
Feasibility design and inspections of an urban stormwater-management tunnel
Dam safety consultations for SaskPower
Geotechnical investigation and design for expansion of ancient gold mine
Scoping study to increase magnetite-concentrate production capacity
Mine closure and reclamation
Monitoring of constructed wetland for groundwater remediation
Landslide stabilization design for an underground coal mine
Stormwater storage facility for major Minneapolis interstate artery
Geologic modeling and mine-plan development for aggregate quarries
Resource estimates for neodymium-rich rare-earth-element exploration project
Water-quality and sediment-dredging study to restore a phosphorus-impaired lake
Waste-gas scrubber design engineering for taconite pellet plant
EMIS implementation and related assistance
Inspection and repair of urban stormwater tunnels
Upgrades and expansion for silica-sand wet plant
Reclamation of legacy tailings site
Bridge movement monitoring
Engineering services for frac-sand operation
Engine compliance tool update
Environmental review and prefeasibility design for planned uranium mine
Natural resources master plan
Embankment stabilization along Highway 73
Flood forecast mapping for city's emergency response and planning efforts
Air-quality permitting and compliance support at pipeline terminals
Environmental permitting and compliance support at terminals
Improvements to municipal flood-risk-protection system
Monitoring and maintenance of remediation system at wood-treating site
Groundwater-surface water study of McKenna Lake
Highway 55 storm-tunnel inspection
Highwall stability assessment
Mine remediation and reclamation
Infrastructure inspection program for Minnesota watershed district
GHG compliance monitoring for oil sands facility
Air-quality-permitting support for refinery assets
Permitting assistance and fen management plan
Whitewater State Park stream restoration
Hennepin County sustainable landscape guidelines
Tailings-management area design and construction
Spillway design for iron-ore-mining and mineral-processing facility
Water quality and ecological improvements to an urban lake
Developing health assessment tools for wind-turbine towers and foundations
Hydrology and hydraulic modeling of a tunnel system
Environmental site assessments for future site of mining and processing facility
Concept-level design of wastewater discharge option
Vapor-mitigation implementation and maintenance at business center
Environmental review and permitting for natural-gas-distribution projects
Minnehaha Park lower glen restoration
Resource assessment and permitting assistance for industrial sands facility
Engineering services for industrial chemicals mine and processing facility
Trona-mining production optimization
Design of an LED lighting system for a downtown streetscape
Fast-track realignment of a storm sewer
Geotechnical assistance for mine expansion at Julienne Lake
Municipal drinking-water wellhouse evaluation and design
Restoration of trout habitat in Vermilion River
Compliance, resource, and process evaluations for potential mining sites
Remedial investigation, negotiation, and design for Superfund site
Stormwater-development reviews for an urban watershed district
Vacuum system design and installation at power plant
Groundwater modeling for water-supply wellfield expansion
Structural and electrical engineering for coal-dryer load-out improvements
Environmental review for natural gas pipelines
Substation relay panel replacement design
Transmission line upgrades for reliable power delivery
preclassification system feasibility study, design, and construction support
arc-flash analysis at Coal Creek Station
Willow River Dam rock arch rapids design services
Geotechnical highwall assessment at Bald Mountain
Above-ground tailings management and mine backfill
Permitting assistance for partial repowering of wind facility
Environmental review and permitting for windfarm repowering
Air-quality services for steel company
Design for spillway replacement at Bond Falls Dam
Hastings levee certification
Analysis of microbial ecology in selenium bioreactor