Transmission line EIS

About this project

Minnesota Department of Commerce
$150 million
completion date

Xcel Energy and ITC Midwest applied to the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission for a certificate of need and route permit for a proposed 345 kV transmission line running from the Huntley substation near Winnebago to the Wilmarth substation in Mankato.

As a third-party consultant for the Minnesota Department of Commerce, Barr prepared a draft Environmental Impact Statement that guided the state’s route selection process for the proposed powerline. The EIS included evaluation of five route alternatives, 19 route-segment alternatives, and three alignment alternatives. Assessing the alternatives required conducting a technical review of a range of complex issues involving human-health impacts, property values, socioeconomic concerns, wetlands, wildlife, and threatened and endangered species.

To assist the public and regulators in comparing routes and understanding the advantages and drawbacks of each, Barr made extensive use of GIS technology. We developed a resource-data-analysis plan listing more than 100 spatial data sets, and then used GIS tools and custom Python scripts to quantify natural resources in and near the corridors being considered. The resulting graphics-based EIS featured multiple GIS maps and figures highlighting the issues most critical to routing.

The final EIS was made available in April 2019, and the route permit was issued by the PUC four months later. Construction began in spring 2020; the line is slated to begin delivering electricity by the end of 2021.

Key team members

Jessica Butler

Senior Ecologist

Nick Nelson

Vice President
Senior Environmental Consultant

Shanna Braun

Senior Environmental Scientist

Aaron Mielke

Senior GIS/Environmental Consultant

Related Transmission lines projects

Stationary-source evaluation for asphalt plants
Pre-acquisition environmental due diligence review
Air dispersion modeling for distributed-generation plant
Third-party transmission-line construction monitoring
Design of abutment wall extension at Dells hydro station
Phase I ESA for copper-nickel project
Siting and permitting for saltwater disposal wells
Ore transportation study
Detailed assessment of phosphorus sources and loading to Minnesota watersheds
Permitting, environmental assessment, and design for copper-nickel mine
Routine electrical, controls, and instrumentation support
Engineering services and permitting assistance for Bison 2 and 3 wind farms
Dam safety consultations for SaskPower
Geotechnical, structural, and civil work for Canadian wind farm
Preliminary engineering for Mouse River enhanced flood protection project
Geotechnical investigation and design for expansion of ancient gold mine
Electric-energy resource options study
Environmental impact assessment for mountain-bike trail
Design services for solar generation facility
Scoping study to increase magnetite-concentrate production capacity
Development of sewer plan and update of model
Upper Sheyenne River erosion and sedimentation risk assessment
Water supply sustainability study for City of Rochester
Capture efficiency testing for ethanol production facility
Study of engineering risks and site feasibility for windpower client
Chemical and biological monitoring of test ponds
Natural resources inventory and stewardship recommendations
Water-quality modeling and mapping for watershed district
Infiltration updates to the Minnesota Stormwater Manual
Geologic modeling and mine-plan development for aggregate quarries
Resource estimates for neodymium-rich rare-earth-element exploration project
Rapid response planning for aquatic invasive species
Environmental review for proposed natural-gas pipeline
Assessment and remediation of former dump site on university campus
EMIS implementation and related assistance
Sustainable landscape master plan for Minnesota college campus
Installation of new auxiliary boilers for power plant
Responding to wind-farm tornado damage
Updating of Lake Superior chemical source inventory
Upgrade of wastewater treatment system
Environmental liability assessment at manufacturing facility
Evaluation of wind-turbine foundation following fire damage
Engine compliance tool update
Environmental review and prefeasibility design for planned uranium mine
Vulnerability assessment of municipal stormwater system
Vulnerability assessment of a city’s aging storm sewer system
Test burn for cofiring coal and biomass
Living-streets planning provides framework for alternative street reconstruction
West Side Flats park and stormwater design
Permitting and wetland delineation for a community solar garden
Penstock replacement at McClure Dam
Stormwater management system for Minnesota district
Non-segregating tailings deposition study
Modeling and failure risk assessment of a municipal storm sewer system
XP-SWMM model update and calibration for Minnesota watershed
Options study and design to restore biomass fuel-handling system
Air permit-to-install strategy and application
Steam-line evaluation at Rapids Energy Center
Air quality permitting for distributed-generation plant
Hiawatha Golf Course alternatives analysis and master planning
Identification of wetland restoration opportunities
Watershed management planning for Minnesota watershed district
Site reviews for solar gardens across Minnesota
Removing dissolved metals from roadway runoff using ferric-oxide filtration
Geotechnical deformation and failure modeling of fine tailings capping
Stormwater-management minimal impact design standards and BMP design calculator
Hydropower facility evaluation and due diligence
Public-space and sustainable stormwater management decision-making framework
Groundwater compliance assistance for CCR Rule
Stormwater-development reviews for urban WMO
Developing health assessment tools for wind-turbine towers and foundations
Design, review, and permitting of mountain bike park
Environmental site assessments for future site of mining and processing facility
Condition assessment and options study for hydro facility
Floodproofing of utility switchyard
One Watershed, One Plan development for southern Minnesota watershed district
Third-party EIS review of transmission line
Environmental review and permitting for natural-gas-distribution projects
Resource assessment and permitting assistance for industrial sands facility
Groundwater-flow model of the Twin Cities metro area
Geotechnical assistance for mine expansion at Julienne Lake
Environmental review for peaking plants
Development of a citywide GIS-based stormwater management water-quality model
Engineering and design services for new truck dumper
Shoreline stabilization and restoration of Lake Minnetonka’s Big Island
Landscape master plan for Minnesota college campus
Stormwater infrastructure management assistance
Compliance, resource, and process evaluations for potential mining sites
Dispersion modeling at five ethanol production facilities
Evaluating tunnel system pressure
Solar-energy-system compliance
Auxiliary boiler installation
Urban watershed stormwater-development and permit reviews
Retrofit engineering for ash conveyance
Ecological residential development design preserves nature and city growth
Vacuum system design and installation at power plant
Redevelopment services for New Brighton Exchange
Energy integration study for waste-heat utilization
Strategic planning for Freeway Landfill
Environmental services for coal-yard decommissioning
Brownfields redevelopment for Mississippi WMO headquarters
Redevelopment assistance for Clyde Iron Works site
Tongue River assessment
Option study and design for air jig dewatering system
Permitting, design, and construction oversight for CCR surface impoundment
Transmission-line permitting assistance
Structural and electrical engineering for coal-dryer load-out improvements
Environmental permitting and compliance support for a refinery
AFFF containment upgrades evaluation
Environmental review for natural gas pipelines
Water reuse evaluation for zero liquid discharge at manufacturing facility
Substation relay panel replacement design
Redevelopment of former Atlas Cement plant
Expansion-related permitting and review assistance
Installation design for alternative energy facility
Aquifer storage and recovery and water sustainability evaluation and implementation